Consequences For Bad Behaviour Must Have an Impact For Anything to Change

I recently told you about a boy who was sent homethey can't have people thinking that can they? It's
from school for swearing -- what a consequence!surprising how many children are just sent home due
Swear and you get an afternoon off school -- great.to appalling behaviour. Exclusion figures would rocket if
Then to cap it all he was allowed back the sameall these unofficial exclusions were made official! Many
afternoon to take part in the class assembly! Oh goodchildren are also on part-time timetables too.
heavens - what are these people thinking of? It's sheerToday's appalling behaviour was ample proof that the
madness. What impact was this 'consequence'previous week's 'consequence' was completely
supposed have on the child? Probably anyone with anineffectual. So the class teacher went to the
ounce of sense would say, 'It just wouldn't have anmanagement and said they wanted me to be called to
impact.'deal with it.
Well, actually it will have had an impact... but not theWhy they didn't deal with it themselves? That's a good
one you'd want. It will have simply reinforced to thequestion. Quite often teachers feel vulnerable and
child that any unacceptable or anti social behaviour willintimidated by management or perceived authority
be suffered by the adults and there will be nofigures - read about Milgram's experiments if you want
significant consequences as a result. In short, you're ato know why - these experiments have also been
soft touch, a walkover who'll put up with any amountrepeated in recent years and with same results.
of appalling behaviour and do nothing about it.School staff also feel unsupported in their efforts in
What you definitely won't see is any improvements indisciplining children. And, in many canses they simply
the child's behaviour -- in fact it's almost guaranteeddon't know what to do. Great credit to them this time,
that the opposite will happen. Surprise, surprise, that'sthey wanted someone to deal with the situation who
exactly what happened. Then they called me to gothey knew would have an impact.
into school... oh boy, he's in big bother now.Did I shout? Did I bawl? No, I didn't. It isn't needed. As I
What had he done? What happened was totallydescribed in Behaviour Bible a child can be told in no
appalling, but in the repertoire of some children'smore than a whisper that you are deeply dissatisfied
behaviour it's almost considered normal behaviour, andwith their behaviour. Your tone, body language, eye
unfortunately the sort of anti social and thuggishcontact, timing, energy and confidence are crucial to
behaviour that adults are often allowing andeffectively managing children's behaviour. The boy
encouraging by taking the wrong action (or no action)was told that he wouldn't be sent home but would be
when it happens.internally isolated in school for 3 days and also when
Following the 'going home for the afternoonhe attended the PRU. He was also told (as were his
consequence' the class went swimming. On returningparents) that if he didn't come to school the
the children were sent to put their bags in theconsequence would still stand until he'd 'done his time'.
cloakroom just outside the classroom. Our little antiThis prepared for him going home with his sanitised
social boy decided to take advantage of the situation,version of events.
pinned a much smaller boy against the wall and startedHis behaviour since then? Very nearly perfect. I've
punching him. Three other boys tried to protect the onevisited the school a couple of times and surprisingly
being assaulted. The class teacher and support(well not to me really!) he welcomed me with a big
worker heard the mayhem and were quick to step insmile. Did he 'throw a sickie' and stay away from
and stop the assault.school? No, he didn't. His parents tried to say he was
But what was going to happen next? They knew thebeing picked on and he hadn't 'done the crime'. This isn't
management people would want the sameunusual. School stuck to their guns and the parents had
'consequence' as the previous week and send the boyto accept that they'd been given a whitewashed
home. It would be an unofficial exclusion -- by not fillingversion of events by the boy. Again not unusual.
in the mountain of paper work involved an official fixedConsequences have to have an impact and give a
term exclusion would be avoided. Too manyvery strong message to be effective. Behaviour Bible
exclusions looks bad on the school statistics. It may betells you how -- there are some actions you have to
noticed that the school has behaviour problems andtake.